How a moment of Newcastle madness became a stroke of genius

Image for How a moment of Newcastle madness became a stroke of genius

Newcastle manager Alan PardewChris Hughton’s sacking seems like an awfully long time ago now. Newcastle fans were devastated and opposition fans were perplexed. It was a move that just didn’t appear to make any sense. During his brief reign at the club Hughton had done a stand-up job and deserved better treatment. When I ask if Ashley was right to sack Hughton, I don’t mean was he right in the moral sense, because Chris had done nothing to merit his dismissal. But surely it is worth considering that it may actually have been the best move for the club?

Many Newcastle fans were flabbergasted with Alan Pardew’s appointment and saw him as something of a step-down in class. He has turned out to be anything but. Discounting the second-half of last season where he seemed to be biding his time until the summer, he’s had an excellent start to his Newcastle tenure.

I remember fans at the time claiming that Pardew couldn’t match Hughton in terms of man management, but it strikes me that Pardew’s getting the most he possibly can out of each and every one of his players right now. Furthermore, I can’t help but feel that Pardew is tactically more astute that Hughton too. Not such a step-down after all.

[ad_pod id=’unruly-video’ align=’right’]

Hughton had managed to obtain the backing of both players and fans, something of a rare occurrence on Tyneside and deserved more of a chance to show what he could do. Mike Ashley’s decision to send him packing could well have triggered a mutiny in the dressing room and potentially another relegation for the club. It was simply awful timing.

Luckily Pardew proved to be a better manager than most people thought and over the course of his ten months in charge he has more than proven that he knows how to galvanise a dressing room. It’s not like Pardew has had an easy ride. He has overseen some high profile departures that led fans to question the future of the team.

Instead, Newcastle has only grown stronger and Pardew deserves a healthy share of the credit for how the club has improved. Given his professionalism and ability, is there anybody out there who really believes that Hughton is the better manager?

Still, that doesn’t make the decision to sack Chris any more right. Strange though that what first appeared to be a moment of madness may end up being one of the best decisions of Ashley’s career.

NothingButNewcastle.com is looking for writers. If you love the Toon get in touch at nothingbutnewcastle@snack-media.com

Share this article


  • Goal Mouth says:

    Most of the ‘constenation’ has been in the media,
    & the less stable (shall we say?) Toon fans.

    So give it a break with the myth building, yet again.
    Not just you, but the media in general.

  • Archie Brand says:

    Come on – lets be honest, with a wage bill equal to half of the rest of the Championship teams combined, if Newcastle failed to come back up Hughton shouldn’t have been sacked, he should have been shot.

    A lot of Toon fans, if honest would admit that they didnt have the confidence in Hughton to take the team forward in the Premiership. Like so many others, Sammy Lee, Joe Jordan etc, he’s a good assistant, but not a great manager.

    Goal Mouth is right – it wass just the press trying to create a story where ther wasnt one

  • geordie85 says:

    WhenHughton was given an 18 month contract, it was clear that he had a season and a half to get us back to the prem. If he did in the first season, he had six months to show as a good prem manager.
    His dismissal came as no surprise to me.

  • Magjoe says:

    i cant believe the comments, Chris Hughton did a great job for the Toon. some people have very short memories. All he did for us was improve the team and improve our league position, who knows what he might of achieved if he had not been booted out by the fat controller.

Comments are closed.